a speech I’m going to present at the community meeting this month.
“Premises”
Robin wanted me to keep it short so:
“Professor Plum did it in the Conservatory with the Lead Pipe”
There it is, thanks for listening!
I’m kidding, but you remember the game of Clue? The object was to determine the murderer, the murder weapon, and the location of the murder. Everybody took turns moving around the board making accusations to come up with the solution to the mystery.
So, what is the premise under which the game is played? That a murder has taken place! That’s the underlying assumption that can only lead to one conclusion.
What I find odd is that there is no body! The rule sheet of the game makes reference to a Mr. Boddy, the victim, but there is no game card, token, or anything to represent prima facia evidence of a murder – a dead body. Such is the power of premise. We say it’s murder, and murder it shall be. But, once the premise is subject to scrutiny, it is evident that all the components of the game are rigged to yield the desired result. Who’s to say the imagined Mr. Boddy didn’t slip in the Library, clonk his head on the table, stagger into the Conservatory and collapse next to a piece of pipe left over from a plumbing project the day before? Maybe everybody else in the mansion was with another who could offer an alibi except for Professor Plum who was outside on a wireless hookup buying stocks for his big Corporate employer using insider trading information? Plum takes a murder rap and the Amalgamated Insurance Guarantee Group LLC avoids public scrutiny. You 401K is safe… move along now.
We’ve agreed that it’s murder, and therefore we will find a perp, the weapon, and a crime scene, and anything else is summarily dismissed.
Are our lives any different? The object is to make money, buy stuff and therefore be prosperous and happy. The perfect summation of this most noble activity is “save money, live better, shop Wal-Mart.” The premise is this is the way to live our lives. This is normal. This is good. Western style consumerism is the pinnacle of human achievement!
It’s all based on a couple of other premises.
1. That infinite growth on a finite planet goes without saying.
2. That there will always be enough work to buy stuff we want.
3. That the initial excitement from acquiring a new gizmo or gadget is worth the price of acquisition, and
4. That like some great cosmic buddha, tomorrow doesn’t exist – only the immediate present is worth considering.
A little side premise here – the needs of the natural world are less than economic growth – ie: the micro ecology of that piece of woodland doesn’t count if it’s where we decide to erect a strip mall, or our dream house in the country. Sorry, that was my obligatory tree hugger statement – back on topic.
Maybe Professor Plum is innocent of murder. Maybe our premises are not so valid after all. But how will we know if we don’t even take the time to examine them? The topic for our meeting tonight is permaculture. That is an entirely different way than we have steeped ourselves in – one that takes quite a bit of effort to really understand. Our current premise is that Business as Usual agriculture is the way to feed ourselves. A good place to start would be to take it off its pedestal and look at it with fresh and unbiased eyes.
Thank You.